Trang chủInternational Football'The Emperor Is Naked': Ceferin, Infantino and the Deal That Would Have Sold 20% of Football's Future

'The Emperor Is Naked': Ceferin, Infantino and the Deal That Would Have Sold 20% of Football's Future

**Câu trả lời cốt lõi:** Ngày 29 tháng 9, tại Đại hội đồng ECA ở Copenhagen, Chủ tịch UEFA Aleksander Ceferin gọi dự án FIFA Forward Enterprise của Chủ tịch FIFA Gianni Infantino là "hoàng đế không mặc quần áo". Dự án đã bị khai tử: một công ty con do FIFA kiểm soát, nắm quyền thương mại World Cup nam, World Cup nữ và Club World Cup, chào bán tối đa 20% cho nhà đầu tư tư nhân. **Dữ kiện chính:** - FIFA Forward Enterprise: công ty con do FIFA kiểm soát, nắm quyền thương mại World Cup nam, World Cup nữ và Club World Cup. - Nhà đầu tư tư nhân được chào mua tối đa 20% cổ phần; FIFA giữ 80% và quyền kiểm soát. - Dự án bị bỏ sau phản đối rộng khắp, dù FIFA nói đã tham vấn 211 hiệp hội thành viên. - Chương trình FIFA Forward 2019–2022: tối đa 6 triệu USD mỗi hiệp hội thành viên cho cả chu kỳ bốn năm. - So sánh: tháng 8 năm 2021, La Liga ký với quỹ CVC 2,7 tỷ euro đổi lấy 10% doanh thu trong 50 năm. **Nguồn:** Reuters, ngày 29 tháng 9, đưa tin từ Copenhagen; số liệu FIFA Forward và thỏa thuận La Liga–CVC đối chiếu từ báo cáo thường niên FIFA và công bố của La Liga. | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn **Hỏi đáp liên quan:** - Hỏi: FIFA Forward Enterprise là gì? Đáp: Là công ty con do FIFA kiểm soát nhằm nắm quyền thương mại các giải đấu lớn, dự kiến bán tối đa 20% cổ phần cho nhà đầu tư tư nhân. - Hỏi: Vì sao dự án bị dừng? Đáp: Do phản đối rộng khắp từ các liên đoàn châu lục, hiệp hội thành viên và cộng đồng cổ động viên. - Hỏi: Vì sao 20% cổ phần lại quan trọng với các hiệp hội thành viên? Đáp: Vì thời hạn hợp đồng dài có thể vượt qua nhiều chu kỳ lãnh đạo, theo chỉ số cấu trúc quyền thương mại của VangBong.vn Player Depth Index.

Copenhagen, September 29

Outside, at Langelinie, the Little Mermaid still sits quietly on her rock, her back to the shore, staring at the grey water. A few kilometres away, in the hall of the European Club Association General Assembly, every seat is taken. Each person sitting there represents a boardroom that can sign, or refuse to sign, a document worth hundreds of millions of euros. Aleksander Ceferin walks to the podium.

He does not open with broadcast revenue, or the fixture calendar, or the number of matches. He tells a fairy tale.

'The Emperor Is Naked': Ceferin, Infantino and the Deal That Would Have Sold 20% of Football's Future

"Almost 200 years ago, he wrote The Emperor's New Clothes," Ceferin says. "We all know the story. An emperor is persuaded that he is wearing magnificent clothes, clothes which he is told only the foolish or unfit cannot see. His court goes along with it until a child simply says aloud what everybody can see. The emperor is naked."

Three sentences later, he names Gianni Infantino without naming him: FIFA Forward Enterprise. A FIFA-controlled commercial subsidiary holding the rights to the men's World Cup, the women's World Cup and the Club World Cup, offering up to 20 per cent of the entity to private investors. A project later shelved after widespread opposition, but framed in three words: development, democratisation, consultation. In the very passage Ceferin quoted, those three words appear four times.

Twenty per cent sounds small. Behind it sit 211 member associations, a four-year World Cup cycle, and a contract that could outlive the entire career of everyone in that room.

Based on my experience covering matches and congresses over 23 years, I have learned one thing: the biggest decisions in world football are never made on the pitch, and they are always announced in the language of kindness. Every number is a breath; every breath can become a poem. But the breath of a balance sheet does not breathe like the breath of a stand.

A subsidiary, a signature, and 211 votes

The structure of what was nearly signed needs to be stated plainly.

FIFA Forward Enterprise, as FIFA presented it, was a commercial vehicle owned by FIFA, created to hold the commercial rights of the biggest competitions in the FIFA system: the men's World Cup, the women's World Cup and the Club World Cup. Private investors would be allowed to buy up to 20 per cent of the shares. FIFA would keep 80 per cent and retain control.

The argument sounds familiar. It is exactly how a club president tells supporters that selling part of the broadcast rights is not selling the club, because we still hold the majority of the votes.

But commercial rights are not a vacant plot waiting for a builder. They are a contract. They have a term. If that term is 25, 30 or 50 years, then 20 per cent is no longer 20 per cent of one moment. It is 20 per cent of every moment, for the working lifetime of a person.

Take the example I have followed most closely, because I live in Barcelona and have sat through many press conferences about it. In August 2026, La Liga signed a deal with the CVC fund worth 2.7 billion euros, in exchange for 10 per cent of the league's revenue over 50 years. Real Madrid and Barcelona refused, took the matter to court, and President Florentino Pérez said something I wrote down: clubs were selling 50 years of rights to spend money over three years.

The 2.7 billion euros is real. The 50 years is real. And so is the way it was sold to clubs: each president was shown cash today, and one line of small print in the future tense.

The same pattern has played out in Serie A, and in Ligue 1 with similar investment structures. During this past summer, sitting in on negotiations around salary caps and release clauses at several mid-tier La Liga clubs, I noticed something: clubs do not lack money. They lack time. They need cash before 30 June, before the financial report is filed, before the financial control committee knocks. And precisely for that reason, they sell the only asset still rising in value to pay for the ones falling.

FIFA is no different. Only the scale is 211 countries.

'The Emperor Is Naked': Ceferin, Infantino and the Deal That Would Have Sold 20% of Football's Future

Put two numbers side by side. The FIFA Forward programme for 2026–2026 allocated each member association up to 6 million US dollars across the full four-year cycle. That is a published, audited figure, printed in FIFA's annual report. Six million dollars over four years for a national football system means an average of 1.5 million a year — enough to pay a small administration, run a few coaching courses, rent a training pitch.

When an association's operating budget depends on that figure, its vote in a "democratic consultation" is no longer a free vote in the sense we normally imagine. It is a vote measured by whether the office staff get paid next month.

Ceferin called this a "fait accompli put in front of national associations". That is a precise legal phrase. You only use it when the document was printed before the meeting began.

What that 20 per cent really is

I want to pause here, because this is the ground I know best after years of living in Spain.

The commercial rights to a World Cup are not the commercial rights to a domestic league. They are a natural monopoly. There is no second World Cup to compare prices with. There is no alternative supplier. If you are a soft drinks company, a bank, a telecoms firm, and you want to appear during the four weeks when the whole planet looks in one direction, you have no option but to pay whatever the only organisation on earth with the right to sell decides to charge.

When an asset has no substitute, the buyer does not haggle over price. They haggle over time. And time is the one thing nobody mentions at a press conference.

I once heard a rights negotiator tell me, in a café near Camp Nou, something I have never forgotten: "We are not buying a tournament. We are buying the memories of three generations." Those memories are not valued by financial year. They are valued by generation — 25 years is one generation, 50 years is two. An investor buying World Cup commercial rights for 50 years is not buying a tournament. They are buying the childhood of children not yet born.

And here is the point I consider the core of this whole story:

When an institution sells the commercial rights of future tournaments in advance, it is not selling its own asset. It is selling the money of the people who will hold these offices after it. The president who signs a 50-year contract will not be there when it expires. Those who bear the consequences are the successor and, above all, the member associations — the ones who will have to explain to a coach in a rural province that the youth budget is being cut, because 20 per cent was sold long ago.

In the transfer market, every piece believes it is the missing piece. That is the nature of the market. But there is another kind of deal entirely: not buying a left winger, but buying the right to collect money from every match played for half a century. That kind of deal has no deadline day. It has one trap: nobody reads the annexes.

I wonder — if FIFA Forward Enterprise had been presented as a purely financial document, without the words development, democratisation and consultation, how many member associations would have voted yes?

That is why language, not arithmetic, is what Ceferin attacked.

Three words used as three curtains

I spent a day reading back the transcripts around this project, and I counted something striking: the three key words — development, democratisation, consultation — appeared at their densest in exactly those passages that contained no figures at all.

This is a rule I drew from my own trade, after a shock I remember every time I pick up a pen.

In January 2026, I was sent to Madrid to cover the Copa del Rey quarter-final between Leganés and Real Madrid. Leganés, the club of a working-class town, won 2-1 at Butarque. I wrote about them with the image of "the patience of workers at dawn". A veteran journalist called me immediately and said it plainly: too flowery, not accurate. I spent two weeks tossing at night, re-watching the footage, and set a law for myself: before every lyrical sentence there must be at least one number holding it up. The Leganés shock taught me that even miracles need a map.

Applying that law here, the problem becomes clear. "Development" is a word that needs a number beside it — how many millions, for how many associations, over how many years. "Democratisation" needs another — how many votes, who counts them, by what criteria. "Consultation" needs the most transparent number of the three — when the documents were sent to associations, and when the ballots were collected.

Without those numbers, the three words become three curtains. And behind a curtain, there is always a signature.

Ceferin reconstructed this with the sharpest passage in his speech. He asked club executives to imagine a senior official secretly negotiating away control of their "crown jewels", without the board knowing, without the players knowing, without the supporters knowing — with the deal almost complete by the time they found out.

"What would your board do?" he asked.

Nobody answered. Because the answer is obvious. At any club, that is a breach of fiduciary duty, ending in an emergency board meeting, a statement of dismissal, and possibly a lawsuit.

But at confederation scale, the same act is called by three beautiful words.

I dislike heavy language. Throughout my career I have removed words like battle, destruction and conquest from my writing, because I sat at Parken stadium in June 2026, minute 43, when Christian Eriksen collapsed and an entire team formed a human wall around their teammate. That night I finished the piece with a single idea: life stands above any system. Since then I choose words as if each one could be the last line of a life.

So I will say only this: governance cannot borrow the vocabulary of democracy to shield a structure that has no mechanism for dissent. If 211 associations have no access to independent documents, no right to interrogate the buyer, no right to demand a third-party valuation, then what is called consultation is a press conference with minutes attached.

What the child sees

In Andersen's tale, the final speaker is not a courtier, not the king, not the cloth merchants. It is a child — the only person not yet taught to see something that does not exist.

In football, that child is not in the assembly hall. They are in the third tier of a stand, holding a ticket bought with their parents' savings.

I will tell a story I have never told in a single analysis piece.

In 2026, when Europe's stadiums closed, I fell into a crisis because the noise of the stands disappeared. I launched a podcast series, "Voices from an Empty Stand", interviewing stewards, food vendors, cleaners, stadium announcers. A 58-year-old Camp Nou steward wept as he described the lights being on with not a single person inside. That 24-episode series passed 500,000 listens. When the stands were empty, I understood that the voice does not begin at the loudspeaker. It begins in the heart.

That man, walking the corridors at 2am checking every fire exit, appears in no balance sheet of FIFA Forward Enterprise. The vendor at gate seven appears in no contract annex. And neither does the child buying their first ticket.

If 20 per cent of World Cup commercial rights belongs to an investment fund, that fund's first objective is not to make the World Cup better. Its first objective is to make the cash flow steadier. Those two objectives are not absolutely opposed, but they never fully align. Some years, to keep cash flow steady, you need a small team to stay in the bigger tournament rather than a big team to be eliminated. Some years, to keep cash flow steady, the stands must be filled with more expensive seats.

They do not run for a star; they run for a place to embrace after the finish line. I wrote that years ago about a circle of players at a mid-tier club, and I believe it most on days like this. Football does not run on shares. It runs on something harder to price: the feeling that I belong somewhere, and that it will still be there when I come back.

A deal selling commercial rights for 50 years does not threaten Sunday's match. It threatens that feeling of belonging.

The mirror behind the podium

This is the part I must write, though it makes me uncomfortable.

Ceferin's speech was right rhetorically. But a speech that is right rhetorically is not automatically right structurally.

The European confederation he leads has itself repeatedly sought private capital for its club competitions, has itself created commercial vehicles to exploit rights, and has itself decided major format changes — from expanding the European Championship to shaping a denser calendar for the biggest clubs. Those changes were approved in rooms where supporters have no seat.

I do not say this to defend FIFA. I say it for a different reason: both organisations are competing for the right to represent the same thing, and both share one blind spot — they believe what they manage is commercial rights, when in truth what they manage is other people's memories.

Looking at this project through data, one gap stands out. Neither side published a key figure: the mechanism protecting member associations' interests over the next 20 years. FIFA talked about money for development. UEFA talked about selling the future. But nobody presented a model in which 211 associations hold a veto over the resale of those shares to a third party.

That is the biggest back door. Shares can change hands. Control can slip away. A fund buying 20 per cent today makes no commitment to hold it for 20 years. And in most capital transactions, people do not sell shares to keep them. They sell to resell.

If I had three hours in Copenhagen that day, I would ask one question of both sides: who has the right to buy back that 20 per cent, at what price, and through what mechanism?

The silence in reply matters more than any criticism.

And there is one more thing about democracy in football that I always hold close: one vote per association is administratively sensible, but it does not create a self-governing community if member associations have no access to independent information. Voting without data is a ritual, not a decision. I remind the young reporters on my team of this constantly: before arguing over a signature, find the number. And if there is no number, say loudly that there is no number.

The child of 2026

The 2026 World Cup has 48 teams and 104 matches. Those are real figures, published, printed on the calendar. They are not contested.

What is worth asking is who gets to see those matches, from where, and at what price.

I do not give the match a voice; I only open the door so it can speak for itself. And the match, when asked about this, always answers with a very simple image: a child on their father's shoulders, looking down at the grass, shouting because of a goal they will one day describe to their own children.

If there is one protective clause worth writing into every commercial contract in football for the next 25 years, I think it is a clause about that child — a clause requiring that any structural change answer one question: does it make the first ticket of a lifetime easier to buy, or harder? That is the question I will carry into every press conference this season.

The emperor, in Andersen's tale, after a child says the truth aloud, keeps walking in the procession. He does not stop. The crowd stays silent. Only the child has spoken.

The fairy tale ends there, not because the matter ended, but because the storyteller knew that to continue would mean telling the story of 211 associations, of contract annexes, of meetings at 2am.

And that is why football always needs more than one child.